Jewish

1900: Abject Squalor of their First NYC Home

Hester Street (1901).jpg

Hester Street,

Lower East Side

Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs, New York Public Library

The Sophians left the oppression of Russia and like the hordes of Jewish emigres of the time, the family found shelter in New York’s Lower East Side tenements.

1900

The 1900 Census documents that the Sophian family lived at 252 Henry Street. All of the family lived together at the time, Morris, Delia, Meyer, Jennie, Rosie, Harry, Abraham, and the smallest, their American-born sister, Gussie. New York City Municipal Birth Records note that Gussie was born on August 13, 1893, to Tillie Pergamentshich and Morris Sophion, both from Russia. From research to date, we believe that they lived in this neighborhood from arrival in 1891, and did not escape until sometime between 1900 and 1905.

[Side note: We all have heard tales of immigrants’ names being changed by immigration record keepers who did not understand their foreign names. Regarding our research, we found many of the records relating to the Sophian and Felix families have the same or similar spelling. It is clear, however, that Harry and Abraham’s mother’s name was nearly inscrutable to many English-speaking recorders—whether census takers, and the record-makers for birth, marriage, and death certificates. In the census records, her first name was variously recorded as Dora, Delia. But in birth, marriage, and death records that indicate maiden family names, she has been recorded as Tillie Bergamishczig, Tillie Pargomeschuk, Tillie Porganischik, and Matilda Peggermat.]

They found housing in Manhattan’s Lower East Side, the Jewish ghetto. It and other immigrant neighborhoods of lower Manhattan were legendary for their sordid, over-crowded, and disease-filled conditions. These apartments were so appalling, they spawned a cottage industry of social reformers who championed minimally healthful living conditions. The activists and government health workers found hundreds and thousands of apartments with no sanitary plumbing, no running water, soot-spewing coal stoves for cooking and heat that compromised breathing and blackened everything from walls to belongings, very long narrow apartments with little light or air ventilation excepting for narrow windows in the front room, and crowding so severe that as many as 12 adults shared sleeping space just 13 feet across. The conditions fostered disease, and produced an infant mortality rate of one in ten. It’s remarkable that Gussie was born and survived!

Jacob Riis in his seminal work, How the Other Half Lives, detailed the blight in the immigrant neighborhoods of Manhattan. Lillian Wald famously founded what is considered the first social service organization, Henry Street Settlement. She built the settlement house just a couple blocks from where the Sophians lived.

Photos from the turn of the century—housed at the, New York Public Library, Brooklyn Public Library, and the Library of Congress—document the conditions of the Lower East Side streets. The website, allthingsinteresting.com, has pages devoted to New-York-Immigrant-photos and to Tenement-New York-photos-facts. They provide a quick snapshot of the base poverty, dangerous and unhealthful living conditions.

Chicken Market, 55 Hester Street, Manhattan, February 11, 1937, Berenice Abbott (American, 1898-1991), Brooklyn Museum; Two women & man in front of outhouses; one woman getting water, Irma and Paul Milstein Division of United States History, Local History and Genealogy, The New York Public Library; Man in kitchen—bedroom with dishes, clothes, irons (1904), Irma and Paul Milstein Division, New York Public Library; Life on the Lower East Side, corner Pitt and Rivington Streets, North, New York City, ca. 1915, Underwood & Underwood, Publishers, Library of Congress.

The Challenges Facing a Jewish Developer

As “perfect” as the site was for Harry’s vision for his next building project, he also faced headwinds in building a new apartment hotel. Nelson’s Rockhill development to the east of Oak Hall and JC Nichol’s Country Club developments south of Brush Creek were known for their exclusionary sales and rentals practices against Black and Jewish people.

JC Nichols was well known for developing deed restrictions that were ironclad and stood the test of time. Many of the restrictions pertained to issues like allowable materials to be used in the home construction, setbacks, and the like. The ones that were most venal were the restrictions of who could purchase or rent in these neighborhoods. A typical restriction read: “No lot shall be conveyed to, used, owned, nor occupied by negroes as owners or tenants.” Jews were not expressly included within restrictions, but they were patently included by practice.

Country+Club+restrictions.jpg

“restricted”

“protected”

JC Nichols was a member of a national league of developers (called the “High Class Developers Conference”) which kept detailed records of their meetings. William S. Worley in his highly regarded book, JC Nichols and the Shaping of Kansas City (1990), recounts that the members worried about selling to “Jews and Orientals.” In their 1917 meeting, Nichols explained that his policy was not to sell to Jews, but acknowledged that four or five Jewish families have houses on his properties through other sellers. He noted that he was getting pressure from Jewish leaders to open sales to Jewish families. Other developers urged him to resist, noted that his resistance would be good for sales, and offered stories of their “fortitude” to cancel contracts summarily when they learned the purchasers were Jewish.

This was the world that Harry Sophian faced as a Jewish developer and that Jewish families faced when looking for hospitable places to live. When Harry Sophian finally purchased this plot of land between Rockhill and Country Club districts, he made an announcement referring to his unwelcoming neighbors and proudly claiming that his building would be enviable.

He specifically noted the “restricted home areas” that surround his Warwick Boulevard site, and extolled the amenities, aesthetics, and virtues of the planned new building. With real estate bravado, he noted that he directed his architects to design “a structure that will measure up to its environment out there on the edge of the Rockhill district. … I told my architects to instill into towering brick and stone the fine residential character of the neighborhood.” The architects were told “there would be no skimping in carrying out a pure Italian design.”

Harry Sophian’s answer to the racist anti-semitic developers:
My architects will design “a structure that will measure up to its environment out there on the edge of the Rockhill district, and .... instill into towering brick and stone the fine residential character of the neighborhood.”
— Harry Sophian